Briefing:
Western Sahara Briefing:
Current Developments and Challenges to Self-Determination
Opening Statement
Chairman Donald M. Payne
Chairman Subcommittee on Africa and Global Health
May 09, 2007
Good morning, and thank you all for joining us.
The purpose of this briefing is to examine the current developments on
Western Sahara and challenges to self-determination as presented by
Morocco’s recent “autonomy” proposal.
Those of us who follow Africa closely are well aware of the long
struggle of the Saharawi people to resolve the 30 years of
conflict over Western Sahara. The last remaining colony in Africa,
Western Sahara remains one of the longest-running conflicts. The
only just way to solve this conflict is to hold a referendum to allow
the Sahrawi people to determine their own future.
This issue is one that I have been following for some years and have
worked closely on with my colleague Mr. Pitts of Pennsylvania. We are
sharing a deep concern over the continued lack of settlement of the
conflict over Western Sahara.
Mr. Pitts, myself and 45 members of Congress, including most of the
Congressional Black Caucus, sent a letter to President Bush 2 weeks ago
calling on his administration to embrace a solution for Western Sahara
based on the respect of freedom and human rights which are the basic
values of the foundation of our own country.
The people of Moroccan-administered Western Sahara have been denied
their right to self-determination and their basic human rights for more
than 30 years since the end of Spanish colonial rule in 1975.
On April 10th, Morocco presented an "autonomy" plan for Western Sahara
in a letter to U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon. The proposal would
impose Moroccan sovereignty on the territory. The autonomy proposal
would be an imposition against the will of the Sahrawi people and
would deny them their right to a referendum to vote on their own
destiny.
Here in the U.S. Congress, there is a long history of support for a
referendum – the opposite of what Morocco has proposed -- particularly
reflected in the unanimously passed legislation (H.Res. 245) of the
105th Congress which expressed support for a free, fair, and
transparent referendum in which genuine Sahrawi people
vote.
The United Nations Security Council has continued to uphold the right
of self-determination. Sadly, the continued delay of this
referendum has brought disunity among countries in North Africa and
could cause instability in this region. In addition, the delay
has caused terrible suffering for the Sahrawi refugees who have
lived in refugee camps since 1975, continuing to hope for the
actualization of the 1991 promise of a referendum for
self-determination held by the United Nations.
In light of the recent autonomy plan offered by the Government of
Morocco, we are concerned about the continued violation of
international law which goes against the ruling by the International
Court of Justice to grant self-determination to the Sahrawi
people. The right to self-determination is a founding principle on
which our own country was built, and it is vital that we uphold this
principle both in theory and in practice.
On April 30, 2007, the U.N. Security Council adopted Resolution 1754,
welcoming Morocco’s efforts. The resolution called upon the parties to
enter into negotiations without preconditions to achieve a political
solution which will provide for the self-determination of the people of
the Western Sahara. It further requested the Secretary-General to set
up these negotiations and to report on their status in two months,
thereby seeking expeditious action.
Although Morocco and the Polisario are reported to have agreed to hold
direct talks on the basis of the Security Council resolution, which
extended the mandate of the U.N. Mission for the Referendum in
the Western Sahara (MINURSO) for six months, it however has to be
considered that after more than a decade and over at least $500 million
spent, there is still no resolution to this conflict. Only a democratic
process would provide a just and lasting solution that will lead to
peace and stability in North Africa. Such a democratic process
would also send a signal to the broader Maghreb region and
the Middle East that there are successful alternatives to violence in
the pursuit of national aspirations.
There needs to be more responsibility on the side of the United States
to pressure our close ally, Morocco, to agree to allow a referendum to
be held. If the Sahrawi [SAW- ROW- EE] people want their country to be
integrated into Morocco, then that is what they will choose. But we
must provide the leadership as the U.S. to respect and uphold the right
to self-determination or we are hypocrites. We cannot say we want
to promote democracy elsewhere and allow the people to be free of
tyranny and oppression there but not allow the people of Western Sahara
that same right.
I have also serious concerns about the repression and violence being
carried out against Sahrawis by Moroccan officials in
the occupied territory of El Ayun . The crack down on human
rights defenders has been going on for years in Western Sahara. It’s
simply unacceptable and we must be clear that – whether the country in
question is a U.S. ally or not – this repression and abuse will not be
tolerated.
Morocco holds up its long-standing history with the U.S. since the
1700’s, being the first country to recognize the U.S. as an independent
country. But this relationship also has a checkered past.
The U.S. used Morocco to prop up the brutal dictator Mobutu in Congo,
which then became Zaire. Then Morocco gave refuge to Mobutu in 1997 as
he fled Zaire due to the popular revolt taking place.
Morocco is also known for propping up dictators in Gabon and Equatorial
Guinea as well. So we have to set the proper example to our
allies and encourage the right behavior, not what is currently taking
place or what took place in the past.
I hope during the course of our briefing today each of our speakers
will give their assessment of the situation with its challenges and
developments.
We are honored to have Ambassador Frank Ruddy with us. He previously
served as Deputy Chairman of the U.N. Peacekeeping Referendum for
Western Sahara (MlNURSO). Thank you, Ambassador Ruddy for being with
us.
Our first speaker is Mr. Jacques Roussellier . He is adjunct scholar from the Public Policy Center at the Middle East Institute.
Our third witness and moderator is Suzanne Scholte , president of the
Defense Forum and Chairman of the U.S.-Western Sahara Foundation.
Welcome to each of our panelists.
Statement by Suzanne Scholte
President of the Defense Forum Foundation and Chairman of the US-Western Sahara Foundation
BEFORE THE US CONGRESS
WESTERN SAHARA BRIEFING
CHAIRED BY CONGRESSMAN DONALD PAYNE
Chairman Subcommittee on Africa and Global Health
MAY 9, 2007
Current Developments and Challenges to Self-Determination
Statement by
Congressman
Joseph Pitts
May 09, 2007
"Mr. Chairman, thank you for holding today's briefing
on Western Sahara, Current Developments and Challenges to
Self-determination. It is vital for all parties involved,
particularly the Sahrawi refugees, that this conflict be resolved in
fair and just way.
I remain concerned that the conflict between these two parties, if left
unresolved, has the potential to disrupt peace and stability in the
Mahgreb region, thus threatening the people and interests of countries
in the region, of the continent of Africa, and of the U.S.
This conflict is an issue of the 21st century that must be addressed
urgently and fairly to the benefit all peoples of the region. The
peaceful resolution of this conflict will provide an important signal
to the North African and the Broader Middle East region that there are
successful alternatives to violence in the pursuit of national
aspirations.
I strongly believe that the only resolution to the conflict that will
last is one that includes a free, fair, and transparent referendum for
self-determination - any other solution may not have the legitimacy in
the eyes of the people that is needed for long term stability.
It is important that the parties to the conflict work together to
implement a solution sooner rather than later, particularly with the
threats our world faces today.